
BENTON

VROOMAN
Two men who were state witnesses in the murder of Jack Reid of Derry will soon be facing a judge for their own roles in the June 2005 killing. Michael Benton, 33, formerly of Manchester, and Joseph Vrooman, 53 , of Las Vegas, will appear before a judge the same day in Rockingham County Superior Court on March 13.
Prosecutors state their case before the Supreme Court in a death sentence for killing a police officer.
►Click here for more on the Michael Briggs murder case
►Click here for more on the 'Jay' Brooks case
BRENTWOOD - John "Jay" Brooks' former business partner says the testimony he gave in three murder trials proves that his insurance policy should cover any liability he faces because a Derry man was killed at his former home in Deerfield.
More Jay Brooks >>>
- > Witness says Knight knew murder was going to happen
- > Defender hammers point home (2)
- > Jesse Brooks asks high court to weigh in on bail request (2)
- > Official: Prison uprising foiled (14)
- > Brooks portrayed as man of music, charity (10)
- > Lawyers seek mistrial in Brooks' case
- > Defense: Brooks had tough youth (11)
- > Brooks: Guilty times 4 (2)
- > State interviewing inmates about Brooks (1)
- > Witness rethinks cause of death (1)
- > Murder details revealed (6)
- > Brooks trial delayed when witnesses balk at testifying
- > Drug use, assault detailed on stand
- > Brooks objects to investigators' questioning family (5)
- > Brooks blamed in jailhouse beating (11)
- > A move to exclude evidence in Brooks trial (8)
- > Victim's family files suit against Brooks (10)
- > Brooks jury selection begins (4)
- > Grudge cited in jailhouse indictment of Jay Brooks (11)
- > Witness list released in Brooks murder trial
- > Lawyer accused of aiding cover-up (2)
- > 2nd man pleads guilty in Reid slaying (1)
- > Brooks' lawyers say NH not equipped for death penalty (4)
- > Las Vegas lawyer targeted (3)
- > Brooks transferred to await trial
- > Charge: Brooks plotted 2 years
- > Bail revoked in slaying probe
- > Prosecutors: Brooks brags, spends while awaiting murder trial (7)
- > Legal legend heads to NH (13)
- > Murder plea in Brooks case
- > Fed: State punishing Brooks (3)
- > Brooks' claim of self-defense needs evidence
- > State: Brooks shipped murder package (1)
- > Millionaire defendant gripes about prison (8)
- > Accused murder conspirator remains free (3)
- > State seeks to revoke Brooks son's bail
- > Derry home sold as owner awaits trial (3)
- > Brooks murder- for- hire case will precede Addison trial (1)
- > Brooks' lawyers want trial before Addison
- > Accused killer seeks trial in June
- > Defense faults NH police in slaying probe
- > The rise and fall of Jay Brooks: Successful businessman to accused murderer (1)
- > State: Slaying of Derry man constitutes murder for hire
- > Fifth suspect arrested in 2005 killing
- > Murder charge for Brooks
- > July 8, 2005: Police mum on probe of suspicious death
Murder conspiracy case goes to jury
By JAMES A. KIMBLE
Wednesday, Nov. 18, 2009
Brentwood – The son of multimillionaire businessman John “Jay” Brooks sought revenge just as his father did when they planned the murder-for-hire killing of their one-time mover in 2005, prosecutors said during closing arguments in Jesse Brooks' conspiracy to commit murder trial.
“It was accomplished by the money and the power that they had,” Senior Assistant Attorney General Janice Rundles said this morning in Rockingham County Superior Court.
Prosecutors spent nearly an hour outlining how accounts by two co-conspirators in the murder of Jack Reid, 57, of Derry, and several witnesses who knew about the murder plot all revealed Brooks’ alleged guilt.
“It tells you the plan to kill Jack Reid wasn’t a secret to anyone who was close to Jay Brooks. It tells you it was a Brooks family affair,” Rundles said.
Jesse Brooks, 32, is accused of recruiting friends for the killing in 2003 and 2005, then making payoffs to a Las Vegas contractor who took part in the June 27, 2005 murder for $10,000.
Brooks’ father, John, is now serving life in prison for capital murder. Before his November 2006 arrest, he was known as one of New Hampshire’s most successful businessmen, founding a medical supply company, PolyVac, which he sold for roughly $30 million.
Defense lawyer William Kettlewell did not deny John Brooks’ obsession or longstanding plan to kill Reid, but said the case against his client was strictly guilt by association.
He also asked jurors to look past the numerous mentions of the Brooks family fortunes, which told of numerous homes and cars spanning from Beverly Hills, Calif., and Las Vegas to New Hampshire’s coastline in New Castle.
“You can’t punish this young man because of his parents’ financial success because it has nothing to do with the decision you have to make,” Kettlewell said. “In this country, we don’t punish people because they’re rich or poor or who they socialize with.”
Reid’s murder became a two-year obsession for John Brooks, who believed the mover he hired to load up two moving trucks filled with family valuables arranged for them to be stolen. The theft happened in the early morning hours of September 30, 2003, at a Brooks-owned warehouse near Manchester Airport.
The theft angered Brooks so much that he declared he wanted Reid dead that day, according to witnesses.
Prosecutors said plans for the murder took a brief hiatus in 2004 before Brooks formed another plan of kidnapping Reid with the ruse of a fictional moving job.
Another contractor, Robin Knight, 57, of North Hampton, agreed to call Reid on a disposable cell phone to set up what Reid believed was a trash-hauling job at a Deerfield horse farm.
Instead, two men led him into a barn where an armed John Brooks and another man, Michael Benton, were waiting. Benton bludgeoned Reid in the head with a three-pound sledgehammer. John Brooks delivered the final blows to Reid’s chest.
“(Reid) was suspected and convicted of a crime he did not commit based on the flimsiest possible evidence,” Rundles said. “The worst thing Jack Reid had to endure that he was unknowingly watched and stalked for two years and how he was ultimately lured to his death because (John Brooks) and the defendant felt entitled to take revenge for his imagined crime.”
Knight was convicted of being an accomplice to first-degree murder. Brooks’ friend, Benton, 33, pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in exchange for his testimony. Vrooman, 53, agreed to become a state’s witness as well in exchange for pleading guilty for conspiracy to commit capital murder and hindering apprehension.
Brooks was the last of the five men to be tried in the case. Jurors began getting instructions from Judge Tina Nadeau at 2:15 p.m.
Click on the video at left for an excerpt from the defense's closing arguments. Click on the one at right for the defense's reaction to the prosecution's closing arguments:
.jpg)



Reader comments